In the wake of Pope Francis’ recent visit to the United States, the biggest question following him in the media is where his opinions fall on the political spectrum. It is not entirely surprising that his visit sparked a critical analysis of his stance on social and political issues. He is after all labeled as an unusually progressive figurehead for a faith increasingly at odds with certain values of contemporary society. Francis is a pope, not a politician, and his opinions should be evaluated for their own merit, rather than their meaning in terms of political debates.
While Pope Francis’ speech to Congress undoubtedly added a political element to his visit, the polarized American political system naturally sets the stage for a guessing game of individuals’ political agendas, including the pope. But as was shown during his visit, where he made both right-leaning anti-abortion and same-sex marriage comments, as well as left-leaning pro-immigration and environmental action statements, the first mistake is in assuming Pope Francis had a political agenda to begin with. Forcing a relationship between the pope and the political spectrum serves only to separate Pope Francis as a figurehead from Catholicism as an institution—at the end of the day, he is first and foremost a Catholic and his opinions on political issues ultimately stem from this identity.
Pope Francis’ general message of empowerment, equality and acceptance of all, to a degree, has generated hope in many Catholics and non-Catholics alike for him to be the person finally capable of reforming the controversy, corruption, and outdated conservatism of the Catholic Church. His excellent public image has allowed him to transcend the categorization as a purely religious leader, and prompted consideration of his ability to act as more of a global spiritual leader. He preaches acceptance and love of all faiths and races, and advocates for the powerless; but perhaps his inspirational image has created too much optimism for his ability to fill a political role.
Despite his progressive image, his sidestepping of sensitive issues in his most recent string of speeches should not be overlooked. For example, his acknowledgement of the enormous sexual abuse scandals, denied and misconstrued by the Church for years, conveniently took a backseat to other topics. When Pope Francis did mention them, he did so in a classic display of Vatican inability to face an issue straightforwardly: Through a string of euphemisms and praise to bishops for showing “courage,” rather than focusing on the trauma of the actual victims themselves.
If people are searching for universal, spiritual leadership in Pope Francis they may find elements of it in his advocacy for equality and love, but ultimately he represents the white male-dominated institution of Catholicism and his opinions are inseparable from this. Trying to place him on the political spectrum skews the meanings of his opinions and obscures their origin. By politicizing Francis’ words, commentators forget what it means to be a pope and analyze him completely out of context.
For a nation founded on the separation of church and state, an ironically large amount of U.S. media coverage was devoted to figuring out how the two come together in Pope Francis. It is credit to his excellent public relations abilities that society sees him as analyzable purely in terms of politics, separate from the religious institution he represents.
People can admire his quest to bring a universal, apolitical message of love, equality, and acceptance to a country so polarized in political discourse and wealth distribution, but cannot ignore where he comes from. What impact he will have on the stubborn rigidity of the Catholic Church remains to be seen, but futile attempts to ground him on a political spectrum are irrelevant in evaluating his contribution to Catholicism and to the wider world.
Universal One Church, Inc.
803 Tallahassee Street
Carrabelle, FL. 32322-3220 USA
Hours: 8:30 – 5:30 EST After Hours: Please Leave a Message
Visit Our Website at: http://www.universalonechurch.org
“The Universal One Church defends the unborn, feeds the hungry, shelters the homeless, educates the young, welcomes refugees, and cares for the sick, both at home and abroad. They believe the Bible is the verbally inspired, inerrant Word of God. The Universal One Church is born, one in Christ, with a precise, but open identity, that embraces the whole world, without exception”
“A vocation is a fruit that ripens in a well cultivated field of mutual love that becomes mutual service, in the context of an authentic ecclesial life. No vocation is born of itself or lives for itself. A vocation flows from the heart of God and blossoms in the good soil of faithful people, in the experience of fraternal love. We are designed with a dreaming brain and a hopeful spirit; it is our nature to envision the life of our dreams. And while dreaming comes easy to us, we must never forget that it takes strength, dedication, and courageous action to bring that dream to life.”
Do you wish to pursue a vocation in ministry – become a minister, get ordained or serve as a wedding officiant? We provide ordination to men and women enabling work in all facets of Christian Ministry within the USA, Canada, UK, Africa, South America, Germany, India, France, Switzerland, Thailand, Japan, Australia, China, Mexico and many other countries throughout the world.
The Universal One Church as the name implies is a worldwide Religious Non-Profit Organization, extending its reach to the ends of the earth and to the every corner of the globe. The Universal One Church offers weekly Sunday Services, Bible Study and faith based programming on the Universal One Church Radio Network through iHeartRadio.